Posted in

Who Has Won the MLS Cup the Most


The MLS Cup is a symbol of supremacy in North American soccer and encloses a driving force that pushes clubs to excel year after year.

Throughout the years, several teams have risen to the occasion, claiming the coveted MLS Cup title multiple times. As we delve deeper into Major League Soccer, we will uncover the stories of the most decorated clubs and revisit their journeys to the summit of North American soccer.

But first, let’s look at the most recent MLS Cup to understand what it’s really all about.

Reliving the Unforgettable MLS Cup 2022 Final

In a match that will be engraved in Major League Soccer ‘s annals, the 2022 MLS Cup Final between Los Angeles FC (LAFC) and the Philadelphia Union delivered a breathtaking spectacle filled with intense drama, unique goals, and a thrilling penalty shootout. On November 5, 2022, at the Banc of California Stadium in Los Angeles, fans witnessed an unforgettable duel that ultimately saw LAFC emerge victorious champions. The heart-stopping moments and unmatched excitement of this historic final have solidified it as one of the greatest matches in MLS history. In this article, we will relive the extraordinary events of that day, providing an in-depth account of the match, the atmosphere at the stadium, and the unforgettable stories that unfolded during and after the game.

The Build-Up

As anticipation for the MLS Cup Final reached a fever pitch, both LAFC and the Philadelphia Union prepared for their biggest match of the season. LAFC, under the guidance of coach Bob Bradley, had enjoyed a remarkable campaign, finishing top of the Western Conference with a record-breaking 73 points. The Philadelphia Union, led by coach Jim Curtin, had also impressed, securing the Eastern Conference title with 67 points.

The Atmosphere

The Banc of California Stadium, home to LAFC, was buzzing with energy as the teams took to the field. With over 22,000 supporters in attendance, the atmosphere was electric, and the stage was set for a night to remember.

The Match

The game kicked off with both teams displaying their attacking prowess. In the 23rd minute, LAFC’s star forward, Carlos Vela, broke the deadlock with a stunning left-footed strike from outside the box, sending the home crowd into a frenzy. However, the Union quickly responded, as midfielder Jamiro Monteiro equalized with a powerful header in the 34th minute.

The second half was no less thrilling, with both teams exchanging chances and engaging in end-to-end football. In the 68th minute, LAFC regained the lead through a thunderous volley from midfielder Eduard Atuesta. The drama continued when Philadelphia’s Kacper Przybylko leveled the score again in the 81st minute, ensuring the game would be decided in extra time.

When asked about the match in an interview, Gareth Bale said:

“It’s always nice to score in finals and I seem to be doing that. It’s important for the club and the fans. We were down to 10 men and it didn’t look like we were going to get anything out of the game, so credit to everyone for pushing and fighting. It’s a great feeling.”

Another interviewer asked him what his journey had been like in LAFC since signing up. Bale replied

“It’s been a difficult transition, coming in with no preseason and trying to catch up. Relocating with my family was also a challenge, but it’s all worth it when you have moments like today. The most important thing was to win the MLS Cup Final, and we managed to do that.”

Extra Time

Extra time saw both teams visibly exhausted, but the desire to win was still evident. Neither side could break the deadlock, but the match moved to a nail-biting penalty shootout to decide the winner.

Penalty Shootout

The penalty shootout was a display of nerves, skill, and determination. After several rounds of perfectly executed spot-kicks, LAFC’s goalkeeper, Kenneth Vermeer, emerged as the hero, diving to his right to save Przybylko’s penalty. Then, Carlos Vela stepped up to take the decisive spot-kick and calmly slotted it home, sending LAFC’s fans and players ecstatic.

The Aftermath

The final whistle marked the end of a match that will live long in the memory of soccer fans. LAFC players and staff celebrated their hard-fought victory, lifting the MLS Cup for the first time in the club’s history. The Philadelphia Union, despite their valiant effort, was left to reflect on what might have been. The 2022 MLS Cup Final was a true testament to the passion, quality, and drama of American soccer, and it will forever be remembered as one of the most exciting and exhilarating finals in MLS history.

Teams with the Most MLS Cup Titles

LA Galaxy

The LA Galaxy have proven themselves to be the most successful team in the MLS Cup, having secured the prestigious title on five occasions. These victories, achieved in 2002, 2005, 2011, 2012, and 2014, demonstrate the team’s unwavering prowess and ability to perform at the highest level over an extended period.

The triumphs of the LA Galaxy have been shaped by an array of exceptional talent both on the field and on the sidelines. Iconic figures such as Landon Donovan, David Beckham, and Robbie Keane have dazzled fans with their skills, while masterful managers like Bruce Arena have orchestrated their success from the touchline.

The LA Galaxy’s journey to MLS Cup dominance is punctuated by unforgettable moments and nail-biting encounters. Among the most memorable are their thrilling 1-0 win over the New England Revolution in 2014 final, secured by an extra-time goal from Robbie Keane, and their commanding 3-1 victory against the Houston Dynamo in 2011, featuring goals from Landon Donovan, Robbie Keane, and Mike Magee.

D.C. United

Another formidable force in the history of the MLS Cup is D.C. United, a team that has left an indelible mark on American soccer. With four MLS Cup titles, they have etched their name in the annals of the league’s legacy. Moreover, their championship victories came early in the league’s existence, in 1996, 1997, 1999, and 2004, demonstrating their dominance during the formative years of MLS.

D.C. United’s initial success can be traced to its impressive roster, featuring legends like Marco Etcheverry, Jaime Moreno, and Eddie Pope. These players and several others formed the backbone of a team that displayed remarkable skill and determination. Their success was also due, in part, to the leadership of head coach Bruce Arena, who later moved on to the LA Galaxy.

One of D.C. United’s most memorable MLS Cup moments was their thrilling victory in the inaugural MLS Cup in 1996. In a dramatic match against the LA Galaxy, D.C. United returned from a 2-0 deficit to win 3-2 in extra time, with Eddie Pope scoring the decisive goal.

Seattle Sounders FC

The Seattle Sounders FC has emerged as a modern powerhouse in Major League Soccer. The team has clinched the MLS Cup twice – in 2016 and 2019. The Sounders’ meteoric rise to the top has been impressive, considering they joined the league as an expansion team in 2009.

Key players, such as Clint Dempsey, Nicolás Lodeiro, and Jordan Morris, have played crucial roles in the Sounders’ success. Furthermore, the team’s managerial stability, with Brian Schmetzer at the helm since 2016, has been a significant factor in their consistent performance.

One unforgettable moment in the Seattle Sounders’ MLS Cup history is their 2016 victory, which marked their first championship title. In a dramatic penalty shootout against Toronto FC, goalkeeper Stefan Frei emerged as the hero, making crucial saves to secure the title for his team.

Other teams with 2 MLS Cup titles are:

  • Houston Dynamo FC (2006 and 2007)
  • Sporting Kansas City (2000 and 2013)
  • Columbus Crew SC (2008 and 2020)
  • San Jose Earthquakes (2001 and 2003)

Now that we have explored the top teams with the most MLS Cup titles let’s discuss some factors that have contributed to their success.

Factors Contributing to the Success of Top Teams

Consistent management and coaching

A common thread among the most successful MLS Cup teams is the presence of experienced and consistent leadership. Coaches such as Bruce Arena and Brian Schmetzer have developed winning strategies, fostered team chemistry, and managed their squads effectively.

The importance of strong leadership and coaching in a team’s success cannot be overstated. A great coach can inspire and motivate players, instill tactical discipline, and create a winning mentality. Successful coaches in MLS history include Bruce Arena, who guided the LA Galaxy to multiple championships, and Bob Bradley, whose tactical acumen helped LAFC claim their first MLS Cup in 2022. These coaches have demonstrated their ability to adapt their tactics to suit the strengths of their teams and their capacity to make crucial in-game adjustments.

Strong roster and talent development

Successful teams in the MLS Cup have consistently featured star players and a solid supporting cast. By investing in talent development, scouting, and player acquisition, these teams have assembled competitive rosters that can consistently challenge for titles.

The top teams in MLS are known for their focus on player development. Investing in academies and youth systems allows clubs to identify and nurture local talent. These players, in turn, form the backbone of successful teams and help clubs maintain a competitive edge over their rivals. Teams like FC Dallas and the Philadelphia Union have reaped the benefits of investing in player development, consistently producing homegrown talent capable of performing at the highest level.

Financial resources and investment in players

Having the financial resources to invest in top talent plays a vital role in a team’s ability to dominate the league. Successful teams like the LA Galaxy and Seattle Sounders have been able to bring in high-profile players, contributing to their overall success.

The ability to scout and recruit top foreign talent has also been a critical factor in the success of many MLS teams. Clubs that have successfully brought in high-quality international players have managed to elevate their performance on the field. For example, the Seattle Sounders’ signing of Nicolás Lodeiro in 2016 played a significant role in their MLS Cup success that year, while Carlos Vela’s arrival at LAFC in 2018 transformed the team into an attacking powerhouse.

Financial Backing

A solid financial foundation allows clubs to invest the necessary resources to build a successful team. This includes signing high-profile players, investing in player development, and providing state-of-the-art training facilities. Teams with deep-pocketed ownership groups, such as Atlanta United and LAFC, have shown that they can compete at the highest level by leveraging their financial might.

Team Chemistry and Cohesion

Team chemistry is often an underrated factor in a team’s success, but it can significantly affect performance. Groups with players who gel well together, both on and off the field, are more likely to succeed. In addition, a strong team spirit can help players overcome adversity and maintain consistency throughout the season. An excellent example of this was the 2022 Philadelphia Union. Despite not having a roster full of superstars, they reached the MLS Cup Final due to their exceptional team cohesion.

Supportive fan base and home-field advantage

A passionate fan base can significantly boost a team’s performance. In the case of successful MLS teams, their fans have consistently provided unwavering support, creating an intimidating atmosphere for opponents and contributing to their teams’ home-field advantage.

In the next section, we will discuss some honorable mentions – other notable MLS Cup winners who have made their mark on the league.

Other Notable MLS Cup Winners

Portland Timbers

The Portland Timbers have made their presence felt in Major League Soccer, capturing the MLS Cup in 2015. The team, known for its passionate fan base and electric home atmosphere, has consistently been a strong contender in the league. The Timbers’ 2015 victory, led by head coach Caleb Porter, saw them defeat the Columbus Crew 2-1, with goals from Diego Valeri and Rodney Wallace.

Atlanta United FC

Despite being a relatively new team, Atlanta United FC has already significantly impacted MLS. Founded in 2014 and beginning play in 2017, the group quickly established itself as a powerhouse, winning the MLS Cup in their second season. Coached by Gerardo “Tata” Martino and boasting a roster that included stars like Josef Martinez and Miguel Almirón, Atlanta United defeated the Portland Timbers 2-0 in the 2018 final, with goals from Josef Martinez and Franco Escobar.

Sporting Kansas City

Sporting Kansas City, formerly known as the Kansas City Wizards, has also tasted MLS Cup success, winning the championship twice – in 2000 and 2013. Coached by Peter Vermes, who has been with the team since 2009, Sporting Kansas City has consistently been a competitive force in the league. Their 2013 victory saw them defeat Real Salt Lake in a thrilling penalty shootout, with goalkeeper Jimmy Nielsen playing a pivotal role in securing the win.

Toronto FC

After years of underperformance, Toronto FC finally broke through to MLS Cup glory in 2017. The team, led by coach Greg Vanney, boasted a talented roster with players like Sebastian Giovinco, Jozy Altidore, and Michael Bradley. Toronto’s victory was delightful, as they avenged their 2016 loss to the Seattle Sounders by defeating them 2-0 in the 2017 final, with goals from Jozy Altidore and Victor Vazquez.

The Future of MLS Cup Competition

Emerging teams and rivalries

As the league grows, new teams and rivalries are beginning to emerge. Expansion clubs like Nashville SC, Austin FC, and Charlotte FC are poised to make an impact in the coming years, potentially challenging the established powerhouses for MLS Cup titles.

Impact of league expansion and new franchises

The ongoing expansion of MLS brings new franchises and markets into the fold, increasing the overall competitiveness of the league. In addition, this growth creates opportunities for new fan bases to emerging and further strengthens the league’s presence in North America.

Increasing competitiveness and growth of the league

With more teams entering the league and the overall quality of play improving, the race for the MLS Cup is becoming more competitive than ever. This development bodes well for the league’s future, as it continues to attract talented players from around the world and solidifies its status as a premier soccer competition.


In summary, teams like LA Galaxy, D.C. United, and Seattle Sounders FC have cemented their legacies by winning the most MLS Cup titles. Their success can be attributed to consistent management, strong rosters, financial investment, and emotional fan support. As the league continues to expand and evolve, we can expect new contenders to emerge, making the competition for the MLS Cup even more intense and captivating. Major League Soccer’s growth and development are a testament to the sport’s increasing popularity and potential in North America.